
The unqualified opinion editorial pundit has been one of the biggest sources of unchecked medical disinformation throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. Their willful ignorance, unassailable arrogance, and a total failure of media outlets to bother to fact check and interrogate their claims before publishing to a sizeable audience has done a considerable disservice to the health of the American public. Often times, reactionary disinformation downplaying the harms of COVID-19 was seamlessly laundered to a more liberal mainstream audience.
A prime example of this phenomenon is Natalie Shure, a writer for The New Republic.
Wrong Then, Even More Wrong Now
As part of an extended Twitter meltdown on September 24th, 2026, Natalie Shure (@nataliesurely) boldly proclaimed:
anyway, demands for eternal public masking aren’t actually about disability justice - they’re about coercing people into accepting an erroneous casual link between mild infection and permanent disability. I wrote this four years ago & stand by every word:

Attached is a link to a December 8th, 2022 opinion editorial in The New Republic titled “We Might Have Long Covid All Wrong,” which is a darkly hilarious and pitiful attempt to revive centuries old medical “hysteria” myths. Back in the “good old days” MAHA seeks to return us to, women suffering from chronic illness were pumped full of useless or dangerous drugs, locked away in hellacious asylums, or even had quack doctors “treat” them with vibrators and even icepicks. Natalie attempts to claim that Long COVID, which disproportionately affects women like herself, is merely “psychosomatic” or Functional Neurological Disorder.
In other words, those suffering are merely imagining it, and can be “cured” with a useless regime of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Graded Exercise Therapy (GET), the latter of which has been found to make Long COVID symptoms worse prior to Natalie’s article being published. Shure will even go so far to attack Ed Yong, an award-winning science journalist who has covered Long COVID since 2020, who also explained this, as making claims that are not “evidence-based.”
Starting From the Bottom & Digging Deeper
This is laughable. Natalie came to her conclusion in 2021, when she wrote in a September 09th tweet that Long COVID “...symptoms basically read like textbook cases of depression, stress and axiety, and are somewhat alleviated by breathing exercises.” Engaging in the precise opposite of the scientific method, cherry-picking poor quality evidence to support her pre-determined conclusion, Shure worked backwards in the lead-up to her now infamous 2022 TNR article. Professional anti-vaccine grifters frequently engage in the same unscientific method.

Earlier in April 2021, she was already on the anti-mask warpath when she whined in The New Republic to “Set Us Free From Outdoor Mask Mandates!” While outdoor transmission of SARS-CoV-2 is lower than indoors, it still happens. This was before much of the nation had been vaccinated, including the entirety of American children. Hundreds of American children will die that year because they were infected before they could even receive the protection of a COVID-19 vaccine, and many, many more will develop serious long-term health complications as a result.
A mountain of research on the impacts of Long COVID since December 2022 has since proven Natalie & her comrades-in-disinfo dead wrong, of which you can read for yourself here and form your own informed opinion:
This compilation is organized by multiple sections affecting numerous different parts of the human body, from the brain, to the heart, and even reproductive organs. You would have to be a brazen fool, or one pathetically unqualified opinion editorial pundit, to claim that this is all merely some form of mental illness. Yet to this day, Natalie continues to proudly feature this laughable joke of an article on her website.
A Single Pundit Can Overrule Biomedical Consensus?
For someone to claim to “stand by every word” whilst simultaneously refusing to review the years of medical and scientific research about the topic you claim to be an authority on that has been published since, this is quite embarrassing for Natalie. But wait, it gets even worse! Only a month after her original article, Public Herald published on January 9th, 2023 a letter signed by hundreds of journalists, researchers, physicians, and people with Long COVID pointing out her numerous errors titled: “The New Republic Has Long Covid All Wrong.” It reads:
“...Shure’s theory is not supported by science and goes against the vast biomedical research consensus ... Since the article’s publication, experts, researchers, physicians, psychiatrists, bioethics experts, columnists, journalists, and patients have identified harmful mistakes that undermine the article’s credibility.”
Natalie has never acknowledged this extensive and well-written rebuttal. She’d already decided that she alone can singlehandedly overrule the medical consensus. Even worse, she will go on to throw out childish insults on Twitter, even going to so far to mockingly compare Long COVID to Havana Syndrome:

This is the same immature antics that all of the worst “Make America Healthy Again” creeps, such as Jay Bhattacharya and Vinay Prasad, have engaged in for years. Prasad is also a fan of Natalie’s work, who exploited it to attack doctors & scientists:

The Liberal-Reactionary Alignment
The painful truth is that many liberal and progressives who supported Biden in 2020 under his promise to “follow the science” soon found themselves reflexively defending his disastrous COVID-19 response, helmed by a business management consultant with no medical or scientific credentials, but instead a long history of ties to companies implicated in Medicare fraud. Daniel Boguslaw and Max Moran wrote for Revolving Door Project in 2022:
“The hasty exit of Zients, the government’s most senior pandemic coordinator, follows his attempt to downplay the health impacts of the disease, encourage the removal of mask mandates, and incentivize a return to the workplace … Over the span of two decades, the health care companies that Zients controlled, invested in, and helped oversee were forced to pay tens of millions of dollars to settle allegations of Medicare and Medicaid fraud. They have also been accused of surprise-billing practices and even medical malpractice. Taken together, an examination of the companies that made Zients rich paints a picture of a man who seized on medical providers as a way to capitalize on the suffering of sick Americans. In the end, it seems to have all paid off.”
Adopting a team sports mentality to public health, this led to liberals embracing anti-mask rhetoric, which contributed to a disastrous 2021-2022 winter of COVID-19 deaths, including tens of thousands of breakthrough infections in vaccinated Americans. In 2022, they ultimately aligned with anti-vaccine reactionaries that the true villain of the pandemic was Americans continuing to employ layered mitigations to protect themselves from COVID-19.
For example, the loudest supporter of Shure’s pitiful screed would be vile anti-vaccine misogynistic sadist Alex Berenson, which should have been reason enough for Shure to have redacted her article and issued a public apology. Alex has wasted years of his one and only pathetic excuse of a life inciting abuse against women and profiting from spreading dangerous anti-vaccine lies. If these are the sorts of allies you’re attracting, just what does that say about the quality of your writing?
The Public Herald letter also points out that:
“Long Covid is a biomedical syndrome affecting multiple organ systems, with evidence of autonomic, vascular, and endothelial dysfunction, viral persistence, capillary rarefraction, impaired cardiopulmonary function, pro-inflammatory and hypercoagulable state, reduced oxygen extraction and abnormalities in T-cells and cytokines. Much of this was known as early as 2020. In 2022, over 3,500 deaths were attributed to Long Covid, which experts say is a ‘a floor of an estimate.’”
It must be incredibly awkward to have your opinion editorial debunked long before its publication, and then nearly four years later continue to insist that you “stand by every word,” even as our understanding of Long COVID has overwhelmingly rebuked you. This is because Natalie Shure is not a serious adult who cares about meaningful discussion or scientific fact; it’s because she’s a petulant brat running her mouth about topics she refuses to understand the basics of. It should have had her blacklisted for committing such an obnoxious act of journalistic malpractice.
In Natalie’s original article, she claims that “...while misdiagnosis does happen, it’s arguably worse to err on the side of biomedicalization,” by making an inappropriate comparison to... C-Sections? This is similar to a conspiracy theory peddled by MAHA crackpots Marty Makary and Vinay Prasad, who have both claimed that Long COVID is part of a conspiracy involving the “medicalization of normal life.” Why does this seemingly well-respected The New Republic writer keep aligning with anti-vaccine propagandists over and over again?
The Media Caused Long COVID?

Instead, Shure claims in 2026 to stand by an absurd claim that “...chronic illness that appeared to be triggered by viral infection could just as easily have been triggered by the trauma of the pandemic itself.” This is a pet theory she read on Twitter ginned up by dedicated COVID-19 contrarians who insist that Long COVID was actually caused by media sensationalism. For example, economist Emily Oster has compared reporting on pediatric COVID-19 to that of shark attacks; a deeply revolting and inappropriate comparison.
This theory is shared by reactionary quack Vinay Prasad, an anti-vaccine crank who, like Natalie, attacked Ed Yong by claiming that he “invented” Long COVID, and identical to Shure’s view, has screeched on Twitter: “Bullshit. No good long COVID data. Lol” - like Alex Berenson, his Twitter buddy Prasad is also a vile anti-vaccine misogynist. Both Shure and Prasad love to throw around the term “evidence based” while rejecting mountains of evidence that contradict their opinion, and making evidence-free claims, such as Prasad’s continued insistence that the COVID-19 vaccine killed children.
In reality, it seems that Shure was the one who developed debilitating trauma because she, like many other well-off opinion editorial pundits, was mandated to suffer the agony of having to wear a mask. It ruined her critical thinking skills and led to an outright rejection of science. She also clearly struggles to reconcile with the fact that her views often align with the anti-vaccine misogynists who celebrate convicted rapists like Mike Tyson and Russell Brand. For example, in January 2023, Natalie appeared on the reactionary cesspool that is The Hill Rising in a segment titled “Libs LOSE THEIR MINDS Over Possibility Long Covid Is Psychosomatic,” featuring an image of female journalist Taylor Lorenz in the thumbnail and the text “HYSTERIA?”
Just How is Long COVID Caused? Perhaps It Might Just Be COVID-19?
When Natalie Shure claims in 2026, against all evidence to the contrary, that there is merely an “erroneous casual link between mild infection and permanent disability” for Long COVID, she fails to account for a mountain of research on the prevalence of Long COVID. When the Biden Administration upheld Trump’s “America First” vaccine policy, forcing middle and low income countries to competitively bid against one another for the COVID-19 vaccines, millions died while nations that were last in line suffered exponentially higher rates of Long COVID. It’s clear that the virus, and not media sensationalism, is the cause of this chronic illness.
For Natalie to confidently “stand by every word” of her original article, she would be able to show the millions of Americans whose Long COVID was cured by CBT/GED. If she was a serious journalist and her writing was evidence-based, this task should be quite easy...yet she simply cannot. These millions, including countless children, still have no treatment or cure. The MAHA crackpots whose myths she parroted are working overtime to ensure it never comes.
Instead, Natalie insists that just like the medical misogynists who diagnosed women with “hysteria,” patients are unreliable and don’t know what they’re talking about. In reality, millions of Americans struggling with chronic illness expel an incredible amount of effort & resources to try and understand their condition. She refuses to accept that many who wound up disabled by Long COVID developed the condition due to “mild” illness. “Mild” simply means that they weren’t hospitalized or didn’t die from the acute phase of COVID-19.
One explanation is that the immune system fails to mount an adequate response for the harm the virus is actually doing, resulting in milder symptoms. This is how many anti-vaccine cranks get away with claiming that COVID-19 is merely a “cold” or “flu,” because the shared symptoms are the result of the immune system mounting a defense. For Natalie to fail to comprehend these basic facts immediately disqualifies her commentary as worthless, and frankly harmful.
The Laziness of the Op-Ed Pundit
In her original 2022 piece, Natalie Shure writes off Long COVID as “a patient-coined term invoking post-viral chronic illness that lingers after sufferers have ostensibly recovered from SARS-Cov-2.” In reality, this opinion editorial writer confused reading junk on Twitter with doing actual journalism, or else she would have known that just a year prior in 2021, Long COVID was recognized by the National Institutes of Health as Post-Acute Sequalae of COVID-19, or PASC. These are the sorts of basic, basic errors that Natalie insists she “stands by every word” of years later.
Worse yet, when looking at research on COVID-19 & viral persistence, it’s clear that this opinion editorial writer with zero medical or scientific credentials fails to comprehend that people suffering from Long COVID didn’t “ostensibly recover:” they’ve actually never recovered. We still have no treatment or cure for this condition, so Natalie would rather engage in rampant denialism - like many anti-science MAHA reactionaries - as a comfort blanket. This is the sign of a weak-minded person with poor moral character.
Worse yet, Natalie shares the same myth of crackpots like former FDA Commissioner Marty Makary, who smugly remarked on FOX News that “there is no Long COVID, there is only Long Anxiety.” They both cite the same single paper from JAMA Psychiatry to try and refute mountains of contradictory research, which is simply not how scientific debate works. Isn’t it quite odd that time and time again, Natalie keeps finding her views in seamless alignment with anti-vaccine reactionaries?
If you want to understand RFK Jr. and MAHA’s rise to power, it’s in large part because liberal pundits like Natalie Shure laundered their lies from the depths of anti-vaccine Twitter into a more liberal mainstream discourse. Now we are all paying an awful price as a result. When will this legion of unqualified opinion peddlers finally admit fault and apologize?
Final Verdict
Natalie Shure went down this dark road because she began the pandemic as an anti-masker, and starting from there, grasped onto any sort of evidence, no matter how poor, to defend the administration’s poor choices. This is the reverse of the scientific method, yet the same method that unqualified pandemic pundits applied time & time again to mislead the public. It led to Shure repeating unscientific garbage she read on social media in opinion editorials.
Natalie Shure should be honest with her audience and the general public: that she isn’t really all that opposed to the war on science & modern medicine Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and the rest of the “Make America Healthy Again” quacks are waging. Much more energy is dedicated to lashing out at the people advocating for layered mitigations to fight COVID-19. She should be honest with herself that, as a woman, she has embraced centuries old, long debunked medical misogyny while repeating myths shared by vile misogynists. However, doing so might require maturity and honest introspection, something which many pandemic pundits have proven themselves incapable of, as it is much easier to snark on social media.
The American history podcast The Dollop, hosted by comedians Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds, often touches upon the painful and agonizing history of medical quackery - with women often paying the harshest price. The duo teach us that we in the 2020s are not all that removed from the people who acted upon awful, horrific ideas - such as hiring an all-female staff to paint radioactive material on military equipment in the 1910s. Or in the 1940s, when Dr. Freeman electrocuted people before ramming an ice pick into people’s skulls to perform lobotomies; another “hysteria” treatment. Or in the 1990s, when Dr. Heimlech injected AIDS patients with malaria as a “cure.”
All of Natalie Shure’s advocacy on behalf of a select few dishonest quacks has proven is that she is just another loud, obnoxious voice of science denial sabotaging the hard work of people who actually know what they’re talking about. All she has achieved is helping RFK Jr. and his MAHA goons make everything worse and everyday Americans’ lives harder. Natalie should be reminded of this fact every time she attempts to offer up her worthless, fact-free opinions in the future.






